To freshen up after a long, tiring day, men need that long bath with a soap that can make their mood brighter in an instant.
There are so many soaps available in the market, but The Soap Guy and Dr. Squatch is the most significant one. The Soap Guy vs. Dr. Squatch, so which one should you consider as your soap?
Picking up a bar of soap for yourself is entirely your own choice, but after having a look at this write up your choice will be a lot easier.
By the end of the write-up, there will be a recommendation from my side. But, the recommendation does not have to be chosen by you, as we know picking a soap will depend on so many personal preferences.
A Quick Comparison Table
The Soap guy and Dr. Squatch both are very renowned names. If you are running out of time or in a hurry, then this quick comparison between the two will guide you through it.
You will get to see the key features and eventually make a choice considering it.
| Specification | The Soap Guy | Dr. Squatch |
| Business type | This is a family soap business. After the year 2000, the family commercially started producing soap and got this momentum as it has now. | This is entirely a personal endeavor. The founder of the brand Jack realized the demand for natural products for personal hygiene. |
| Longevity of the soap | It has got a very positive review from the consumers and it seems to have longer longevity in comparison with other natural soaps. Of course, there are some other factors associated with it. | Though it stays for 2-3 weeks according to the makers some users say it can not even manage to remain for two weeks. It disappointed the users significantly. |
| Size | The Soap Guy’s products are sold as either loafs that can be cut to size or individual pre-wrapped bars. | The size of this soap bar is 3″ x 3″ x 1″. |
| Weight | The soap guy soap weighs approximately 7 ounces each. | Though Dr. Squatch bar says 5 OZ., ALL bars weighed between 4.12 ounces and 4.66 ounces. |
| Aroma | It has the all-natural aroma of different types. | There is a claim of a different aroma there, but there is some controversy regarding it. |
| Price | The price is determined according to the volume of the soaps. | Per soap, the price is around $36 and there might be some discount with it. |
| Age of business | This business is older in comparison with Dr. Squatch. | This business is comparatively new. |
| Authenticity | After years and years of works, the family created the products, when it came to a better state they decided to commercially produce it for the people. | There is a very common saying that Dr. Squatch used to buy products or ingredients from the Soap guy. Some people say that even after capturing the market share Dr. Squatch is still dependent on The Soap Guy for some of its ingredients. |
| Review | Comes with a more positive review from the customers. | There are still some controversial topics around. |
Key Differences Between The Soap Guy And Dr. Squatch
So, here are the key differences between The Soap Guy and Dr. Squash.
Ingredients
The first big difference between The Soap Guy and Dr. Squatch is where they source their ingredients.
The Soap Guy
This company uses primarily US-sourced ingredients. Their bars contain:
- Olive oil
- Coconut oil
- Shea butter
- Avocado oil
- Castor oil
- Essential oils
They avoid artificial or synthetic ingredients.
Dr. Squatch
Dr. Squatch uses a combination of US-sourced and imported ingredients:
- Olive oil
- Coconut oil
- Pine tar
- Shea butter
- Citric acid
- Essential oils
While their olive oil, coconut oil, and shea butter are sourced domestically, they import pine tar and certain citrus essential oils like bergamot from overseas.
Scents
Both soap makers offer a wide selection of masculine, outdoorsy scents.
The Soap Guy Scents
- Pine Tar
- Bay Rum
- Sandalwood
- Teakwood
- Fresh Falls
Dr. Squatch Scents
- Pine Tar
- Cold Brew Cleanse
- Alpine Sage
- Fresh Falls
- Wood Barrel Bourbon
There’s definitely overlap in the woodsy, outdoorsy scent profiles. Dr. Squatch has more unusual scents like cold brew coffee and bourbon, while The Soap Guy sticks to traditional men’s fragrance types.
Price
Pricing is very similar between the two brands. Both sell standard 5-6 ounce soap bars for $6 to $9 each depending on the formula.
For comparison:
- The Soap Guy Pine Tar Bar: $7
- Dr. Squatch Pine Tar Bar: $6
- The Soap Guy Sandalwood Bar: $8
- Dr. Squatch Wood Barrel Bourbon Bar: $9
Quantity discounts are available for bulk purchases direct from either soap maker.
Buying Options
You can purchase bars individually or by subscription from both brands. However, Dr. Squatch offers steeper subscription discounts.
The Soap Guy
- Individual bars for sale on their website
- Available via Amazon and other online retailers
- No subscription option
Dr. Squatch
- Individual or subscription bars on their website
- Sold on Amazon
- Subscription discounts up to 25% off
Subscribing to recurring deliveries saves the most money if you are a loyal Dr. Squatch user.
Manufacturing
Here’s where we see the biggest difference between the two soap companies.
The Soap Guy
- Handmade in small batches in Tennessee
- Bars cured 4-6 weeks
- Manufacturing facility open for tours
Dr. Squatch
- Manufactured in California but uses imported ingredients
- Bars cured for a minimum of 6 weeks
- No manufacturing facility tours offered
The Soap Guy pledges top-notch transparency – proudly made in the USA from US ingredients. Dr. Squatch sources globally and is less transparent about actual manufacturing practices.
Quality
Both companies produce high quality handmade soap using traditional processes like cold pressing and extended curing times. However, The Soap Guy uses more premium ingredients and cures bars longer.
The Soap Guy
- Cold pressed in small batches
- Aged 4-6 weeks before sale
- Rich, moisturizing lather
- Essential oil fragrances
Dr. Squatch
- Pine tar imported from Europe
- Cured at least 6 weeks
- More drying than The Soap Guy bars
- Uses natural and synthetic fragrance
The Soap Guy also offers more nourishing formulas with added moisturizers like shea butter and avocado oil. Their curing process enhances bar quality.
Customer Service
The soap makers provide comparable customer service options:
The Soap Guy
- Contact form online
- Responsive email support
- 30 day money back guarantee
Dr. Squatch
- Email and phone support
- 30 day money back satisfaction guarantee
- Can pause or cancel subscription anytime
Both brands aim to please customers. Check their websites for current policies.
Ethics
Dr. Squatch has faced some controversy over their marketing tactics and manufacturing opacity.
Some criticisms include:
- Misleading ads about being “small batch” when mass produced
- Refusal to disclose manufacturing location
- Importing ingredients despite “made in USA” claims
The Soap Guy has been transparent from the start about processes and sources. They offer a true handmade, small batch product made ethically in the USA.
Business type
There is a significant difference between the type of business, as the Soap Guy is a family business, running the business for quite a long time.
On the other hand, Dr. Squatch is a one-man army business. The founder started the business following his passion to produce natural hygiene products.
Longevity Of The Soap
The Soap Guy soaps remain for 3 to 5 weeks. The users mostly have a positive review regarding the longevity of this product.
Whereas Dr. Squatch remains 2-3 weeks, but the users said the soap remains for lesser days. This is another reason for the controversial review of this soap.
Size Variation
The Soap Guy soaps are mostly sold as loaves, and you can cut them. You can also get it by individual pre-wrapped bars. The size of Dr. Squatch is 3″ x 3″ x 1″.
Quick Summary Of The Differences
Here is a quick summary;
- The soap guy is a family business and Dr. Squach is an individual business.
- The soap guy remains usable for a longer time.
- The aroma is entirely natural for the soap guy.
- The size of the soaps also differs.
- The soap guy has more weight.
- The soap guy is comparatively cheaper.
- The soap guy is an older business.
Common Similarities of The Soap Guy And Dr. Squatch
- Natural Ingredients
Both the brands claim to use all-natural ingredients. Especially the Soap Guy is continuing the business from the very beginning based on all the elements of the natural sources.
Thus, gaining acceptance among the users over time.
- Multiple Product Lines
Both this brand offers multiple product lines to their users. The Soap Guy is very popular for its lucrative bath bombs.
- Multiple Fragrances
The soaps from both brands come with different fragrances. They claim all these fragrances are natural and this is their ultimate selling point to their customer.
A Quick Summary of The Similarities
- Here is a quick summary of the similarities,
- Made of natural ingredients.
- Having multiple fragrances.
- Multiple product lines in the business.
So, Which One Stands Out?
Well, it is already being mentioned earlier, everyone has their personal preferences. So no matter what I recommend, it’s okay if you think the other one suits you the best.
Here, I would undoubtedly pick soaps from the soap guy and there are multiple reasons behind it.
- Firstly, it is a very well-known and reputed business.
- Secondly, they offer fine products made of all-natural elements having amazing smell also the soap remains for a long time.
- Thirdly, the price of the soap is also pretty reasonable.
Frequently Asked Question (FAQs)
The Dr. Squatch soap lasts for 2-3 weeks. The longevity is a bit controversial topic from the side of the users as they claim this soap remains less than the mentioned time frame.
But from the manufacturer’s side, they say, the longevity of the soap would vary depending on the usage type of the soap.
Yes, it is completely natural. The manufacturer procures all the best quality natural ingredients and produces this homemade soap for their customers.
To get all these natural ingredients, all the soaps are produced in Northwest Indiana.
The Squatch Soap is not manufactured to be antibacterial but like most natural soaps, it is also effective in terms of fighting most infectious illnesses.
It also plays a good role in maintaining good hygiene.
Many consider The Soap Guy a better quality alternative than Dr. Squatch. Their soap contains premium moisturizing ingredients, longer cure time, ethical manufacturing, and transparency about processes.
The Soap Guy provides a top-notch handmade bar soap made meticulously from high-end ingredients sourced and processed in the USA. The premium quality and ethical production make the price worthwhile.
Dr. Squatch has faced backlash for misleading marketing about being a small batch soap maker when they actually mass produce soap. They also refuse to disclose their manufacturing facilities.
Wrapping Things Up!
If you are still wondering about The Soap Guy vs. Dr. Squatch then now you know most of the pros and cons. Now you pick or try these out, then pick the one that suits you the best.
Since the preference of soap of an individual is absolutely a personal choice, trying both the soaps will give you a better insight about the two soaps.
