Are you planning to install a bathtub or replace an old one?
Both Princeton and Villager are good options. Yet, It’s overwhelming to decide but you will find your pick at the end of reading my Kohler Villager vs. American Standard Princeton review.
Imagine how it would feel about spending hundreds of dollars on a below-average bathtub. It would be a disaster. In this article, you will see a detailed comparison between two top-class bathtubs. After knowing comprehensively about them, you can make your decision.
So, let’s begin.
A Quick Comparison Table
Here is a quick comparison table between Kohler Villager and American Standard Princeton bathtubs:
| Aspects | Kohler Villager | American Standard Princeton |
| Special Feature | Left And Right Drain Option | Excellent Heat Retention |
| Size | Smaller | Slightly Bigger |
| Available Colors | 5 | 1 |
| Comfort | Less Comfortable | More Comfortable |
| Weight | 316 lbs. | 96 lbs. |
| Water Capacity | Less Capacity | More Capacity |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime | Limited Lifetime for Residence, 10 Years for Commercial |
| Price | Significantly Higher | Lower |
In-Depth Differences Between Kohler Villager And American Standard Princeton
Because you know the basic differences between these two bathtubs, it’s time we get into more details. In order to make the right pick, you have to have a clear understanding of them.
Here are some key differences between Kohler Villager and American Standard Princeton:
- Features
Kohler Villager and American Standard Princeton are both packed with superior features. Let’s see what they have to offer.
Kohler Villager offers an integral apron so that you can install it easily and quickly. With its Safeguard feature, you will get a slip-resistant surface on the bath floor.
This alcove bathtub is made from Kohler’s signature enameled cast iron. On top of that, you will get integral lumber support with the Villager tub.
Moreover, you can choose between left and right drain location options.
On the contrary, American Standard uses a durable and cost-effective cast iron alternative to make Princeton tubs. As lighter than cast iron, the tub is relatively easy to handle.
Plus, its excellent heat retention feature will keep your bath water warm for a long time.
With StanSure slip resistance, the Princeton tub comes with a textured surface which is pretty easy to clean. Each time you will have a comfortable bath because of the lumbar support that comes with the tub.
On top of that, a beveled headrest and slip-resistant surface will only make sure you have a safe and enjoyable bathing experience. But Princeton tub only offers a right-hand drain.
- Bathtub Size
Bathtub size is essential because it determines how much space it will take in your bathroom. Kohler Villager tub is 60 inches long, 30-¼ inches wide, and 14 inches high.
On the contrary, American Standard Princeton is 60-1/8 inches long, 30 inches wide, and 16 inches wide. As we can see, they are mostly similar in length and width. But Princeton is 2 inches higher than Kohler Villager.
- Available Colors
Sometimes you might want your bathtub other than white color. In that case, Kohler Villagers bring good news for you. Their bathtubs are available in 5 different colors.
You can choose between White, Biscuit, Almond, Ice Grey, and Wild Rose.
In contrast to Kohler Villagers, American Standard Princeton bathtubs do not offer multiple colors. They are only available in standard white color. So, no color option is available here.
- Comfort Level
When it comes to comfort, both tubs are top in their class.
But according to features and customer reviews, American Standard Princeton is more comfortable than Kohler Villagers.
Kohler Villager offers integral lumbar support for maximum comfort. Plus, its Safeguard anti-resistant surface makes it safe for users.
On the other hand, contoured lumbar support coupling with a beveled headrest and slip-resistant surface makes American Standard Princeton tubs maximum comfortable and safe.
- Weight Differences
Weight is particularly crucial for bathtubs. Before choosing one, you must consider how much weight your bathroom floor can tolerate. Plus, tubs with more weights are an extra hassle for shipment and bringing up your home.
On that note, a Kohler Villager tub weighs 316 lbs. or 143 kg. To be honest, it’s a lot of weight for a tub. Enameled cast iron is responsible for this massive weight.
In contrast, an American Standard Princeton weighs only 96 pounds. Using an alternative material to cast iron pays off double-fold here. Because of the less weight, you can easily bring this tub to your home, especially if you live on the upper floors.
- Water Capacity
If you look at the dimension, you will find that American Standard Princeton is bigger than Kohler Villager. So, naturally, it will hold more water.
A Kohler Villager can hold up to 33 gallons of 124.9 litters of water. On the contrary, a Princeton tub can hold a maximum of 42 gallons of water, significantly more than its counterpart.
- Price
Here comes a crucial factor in choosing a bathtub. The American Standard Princeton bathtub will cost you a lot less than the Kohler Villager.
In fact, the price of Kohler Villager is almost double that of American Standard Princeton!
Which Bathtub Is Best For You?
My discussion has given you all the facts and information you will require to make a choice. Now it’s your turn to choose a preferred one for yourself.
But if you ask my suggestion, I would tell you to go for American Standard Princeton.
Other than the name, I don’t see any reason why you should spend almost double the price to buy Kohler Villager. You will get every feature in American Standard Princeton and more.
It’s more comfortable, costs almost half, holds more water, and weighs nearly half. Tell me one reason why you should choose Kohler Villagers over Princeton.
Frequently Asked Question (FAQ)
American Standard bathtubs are famous for their lower price and competitive quality. You’ll get quality products at a lower price from them. So, yes, their bathtubs are of good quality.
The Kohler Villager bathtub is made from enameled cast iron. That’s why its weight is significantly high. A Kohler Villager tub weighs 316 pounds or 124.9 kg.
Among many other things, a tub’s comfort depends on its shape. Bathtubs come in different shapes. But oval-shaped bathtubs are the most comfortable ones with rounded features and proper lumbar support.
The longevity of a bathtub depends on the materials it has made from. Materials like cast iron, stone resin, and recyclable copper are the most durable.
Final Thoughts
After a hectic day, a warm bath in your bathtub can be extremely relaxing. As tempting as it may, a wrong choice of tub can take it all away.
After going through my Kohler Villager vs. American Standard Princeton, no way, you will make a bad pick. It’s your turn now to go ahead and bring the right one home.
Can tubs with aprons have the apron tiled over? The description I am looking at shows the Princeton as an alcove/tile tub, making me think that it can be tiled over….thanks