Are you planning a bathroom renovation or simply looking to replace your old toilet?
Then, you’re probably stuck in the whirlwind of options available out there. Among the most popular brands are Kohler and American Standard, boasting models such as the Highline and Champion 4 respectively.
Today, we’re going to dive deep into these models and compare them head-to-head. By the end of this article, you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Features | Kohler Highline | American Standard Champion 4 |
| Flushing System | Class Five Technology | 4″ Wide Flush Valve |
| Comfort and Accessibility | Comfort Height Seating | Right Height Design |
| Cleaning and Maintenance | Regular | EverClean Surface |
| Price | Slightly Higher | Mid-Range |
| Warranty | Varies by Retailer | 10-year Warranty |
| Design | Versatile Classic Design | Standard Design |
| Installation | Might be Challenging | Generally Easier |
| Included Toilet Seat | Varies by Model | Not Included |
Kohler Highline: The High Performer
First up, let’s delve into the specifics of the Kohler Highline. This is a highly rated model from the well-known and respected Kohler brand.
Pros of the Kohler Highline
- Efficient Flush: The Kohler Highline comes with the Class Five flush technology, offering tremendous bulk waste flushing performance and best-in-class bowl cleanliness. This ensures that a single flush is all you need, saving water in the long run.
- Comfort Height: The Kohler Highline toilet has an ‘elongated bowl’ design with ‘comfort height’ seating, mimicking the height of a standard chair. This makes sitting down and standing up easier for most adults, especially the elderly or those with mobility issues.
- Versatile Design: The design is sleek and versatile, fitting perfectly into different bathroom decors. The Highline Classic design is inspired by traditional and modern bathrooms, making it a good fit regardless of your existing bathroom style.
Cons of the Kohler Highline
- Installation Challenges: Some users have reported that the installation process for the Kohler Highline can be slightly challenging, particularly for those without plumbing experience.
- Price Point: The Highline model comes with a slightly higher price tag compared to other models in the same category.
American Standard Champion 4: The Sturdy Champion
Next, we will talk about the American Standard Champion 4, another top-notch option for homeowners.
Pros of the American Standard Champion 4
- Powerful Flush: The Champion 4 features a 4″ wide flush valve that is the industry’s largest, enabling a faster and more powerful flush. It also boasts a larger trapway, effectively reducing the chances of clogging.
- Easy to Clean: The Champion 4 comes with an EverClean surface that inhibits the growth of stain and odor-causing bacteria, mold, and mildew. This ensures your toilet stays cleaner for longer periods, reducing the amount of time and effort you need to devote to maintenance.
- Longevity: The Champion 4 is designed to be a long-lasting model. It even comes with a 10-year warranty, demonstrating American Standard’s confidence in their product’s durability.
Cons of the American Standard Champion 4
- Height Issue: While some users appreciate the ‘right height’ design of the Champion 4, others find it too tall. This aspect can make it less suitable for children and shorter adults.
- Seat Not Included: A minor inconvenience is that the Champion 4 doesn’t include a toilet seat, which means you’ll have to buy one separately.
Differences between Kohler Highline & American Standard Champion 4
While both the Kohler Highline and American Standard Champion 4 toilets are high-quality options for any household, they do come with certain key differences that could impact your decision.
- Flushing System
While both models are known for their efficient flushing, the systems they use differ. The Kohler Highline uses Class Five flushing technology, renowned for its ability to handle bulk waste and keep the bowl cleaner.
On the other hand, the American Standard Champion 4 uses a 4″ wide flush valve – the industry’s largest – to ensure a faster, more powerful flush. Its larger trapway also minimizes the chances of clogging.
- Comfort and Accessibility
Both models boast of ‘comfort height’ seating but the interpretations of this term differ. The Highline is designed to mimic the height of a standard chair, which is easier for most adults.
However, some users have reported that the Champion 4’s ‘right height’ can be a tad tall for children and shorter adults.
- Cleaning and Maintenance
When it comes to cleaning and maintenance, the American Standard Champion 4 takes the lead with its EverClean surface.
This surface inhibits the growth of bacteria, mold, and mildew, ensuring the toilet stays cleaner for longer. This feature is absent in the Highline model.
- Price and Warranty
While both models are relatively higher priced than other options in the market, the Kohler Highline typically comes with a slightly higher price tag.
However, it’s worth noting that the Champion 4 offers a generous 10-year warranty, highlighting its durability and the brand’s confidence in the product. The Highline’s warranty can vary depending on the retailer, so it’s worth double-checking this detail before purchase.
Choosing between the Kohler Highline and the American Standard Champion 4 can be challenging, but understanding their key differences will undoubtedly aid in your decision-making process.
As with any purchase, your specific needs, budget, and personal preferences should guide your choice.
Final Verdict
Deciding between the Kohler Highline and American Standard Champion 4 can be tricky. Both offer high-quality build, efficient flush systems, and sleek designs. It ultimately comes down to individual needs and preferences.
For those seeking comfort and design versatility, the Kohler Highline could be a great choice. However, if you’re after power, longevity, and easy maintenance, the American Standard Champion 4 might suit you better.
Choosing the right toilet involves more than just aesthetic appeal. It’s about efficiency, comfort, ease of cleaning, and, of course, value for money.
So, weigh the pros and cons, consider your specific needs, and you’re bound to make the right choice, be it the Kohler Highline or the American Standard Champion 4.
