Deodorant is something we are very familiar with for our daily body care routine. But do you know most common deodorants on the market are synthetic, and they come with various health risks and other issues?
To protect you from these health risks comes natural deodorants like Schmidt’s and Native. So, today I’ll discuss Schmidt’s vs Native deodorant, two of the most popular natural deodorant options on the market, and see which one performs better.
Let’s begin.
A Quick Comparison Table
Before we go any further, let’s have a quick look at this primary comparison table between these two natural deodorants. It’ll help you better understand the differences as we advance.
| Specification | Schmidt’s | Native |
| Antiperspirant | No | No |
| Ingredients | Aluminum-free, Natural agents | Aluminum-free, Natural agents |
| Break-in Period | Two Weeks | Few days |
| Dryness Protection | Good | Better |
| Number of Fragrance | 5 | 7 |
| Price | Less Expensive | Expensive |
Key Differences Between Schmidt’s And Native deodorant
Before you decide about Schmidt’s and Native deodorant, there are different factors you need to consider.
All these factors combined truly determine how a deodorant performs.
In this section, I’ll discuss each of these deodorants and show you which one performs best from different aspects.
- Ingredients
As advertised, both Schmidt’s and Native use all-natural ingredients. The ingredients list makes these deodorants separate from the synthetic ones sold on the market.
What each of these deodorants carries might be slightly different, but it’s very clear what these deodorants are free of.
These deodorants are free of chemical ingredients like aluminum salt, parabens, phthalates, talc, and gluten.
Different studies showed that these ingredients are extremely harmful to your body, including potential connection to cancer.
The lack of aluminum might reduce the antiperspirant ability, but it’s worth considering these natural deodorants’ safety.
- Odor Protection
The main job of a deodorant is to offer odor protection. In that regard, both Schmidt and Native have done a great job.
After using both deodorants on intense hot summer days, I have to say the odor protection and freshness offered by these natural deodorants was beyond my expectations.
Admittedly, you won’t get the odor protection offered by those synthetic deodorants, but these natural ones hold on their own pretty well.
I experienced a little odor once or twice sometimes, but mostly both deodorants just crushed the sniff test easily.
- Moisture
Since I have already mentioned above that both Schmidt’s and Native are free of aluminum salt, these deodorants won’t stop your armpit from sweating.
So there will be some sweat and moisture, but that won’t affect the deodorant’s odor protection.
Additionally, Native deodorants have tapioca starch from the cassava plant in them, which allows them to absorb the moisture instead of just barring the sweat like aluminum. So, you can expect to say dry throughout the day.
Though the odor protection is somewhat the same, Schmidt, unfortunately, lacks the feature of absorbing the moisture. So, in the moisture department, Native seems to be the winner.
- Skin Sensitivity
Though we are talking about natural deodorants here, they are not free from skin irritation.
Especially if you have got sensitive skin, some fragrance of these deodorants can be an issue for you.
Fortunately, both Schmidt’s and Native have got few fragrances that are skin sensitive. So you can get one of those if you have skin issues.
Schmidt’s has even taken it one step further with their sensitive skin formula.
However, some users of Schmidt’s also complained about the oily essence and how it left stains on their clothes and darkened their underarm.
Though it’s not a case everyone has faced, you should keep it in mind. Apart from this slight issue from Schmidt’s, both deodorants are great for sensitive skin.
- Fragrance
The fragrance is a major consideration for everyone buying a new deodorant. After all, that deodorant has to go well with your personality and likings, right? So, both brands are offering lots of variations in the fragrance department.
While Schmidt’s has five fragrances, Native comes with seven. So no matter what type of scent you like, there is something for everyone out there.
None of the fragrances is overbearing yet powerful enough to give you the fresh vibe and cover-up for the antiperspirant ability.
- Break-in and Effective Period
This here is one of the key differences between Schmidt’s and Native’s deodorant.
The break-in period and effective period decide how long the deodorant will serve on your body and how long it’ll take to get adjusted.
While both deodorants have somewhat the same effective period, the break-in period seems to differ.
As I mentioned earlier, natural deodorants are not as powerful as regular ones.
So, occasionally you might have to apply it multiple times depending on your day, whether it’s Schmidt’s or Native.
Native can take up to two weeks to get adjusted to your body if you are switching from an aluminum-based deodorant in terms of the break-in period.
This is because the previous aluminum deodorant sort of creates a layer on your armpit that takes time to go out. On the other hand, Schmidt’s seem to start working within a few days of use. So if you are looking for quick results, you are better off with Schmidt’s deodorant.
- Price
Deodorants are always pretty cheap, so the price isn’t going to be an issue for everyone. But if it’s important for you, you should know that natural deodorants tend to be a bit pricier than regular deodorants.
Still both Schmidt’s and Native are offering their products at a pretty accessible price.
While Schmidt’s stick costs only $9, Native’s stick is on the pricier side with a price tag of around $12. If you are running low on budget, you should get Schmidt’s deodorant.
So, Which Natural Deodorant Performs Better Collectively?
As you can see, both deodorants have their fair share of pros and cons here, which makes it extremely difficult to choose one.
However, Native gets my vote as the better option as a natural deodorant considering the better moisture absorption.
The break-in period and higher price can be an issue for some. In that case, you can also pick Schmidt’s deodorant.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Antiperspirant’s only job is to prevent sweating, a normal bodily function, using an aluminum-based compound. On the other hand, deodorants let our body sweat but keep the odor away by preventing bacterial buildup and different fragrances.
There is no fixed period here as it highly depends on your day and how you are using it. While most natural deodorants claim to offer 24-hour protection, you might have to reapply it several times, depending on your daily activity.
Though it’s most likely to happen with antiperspirants, natural deodorants are also not out of danger. Especially those containing coconut oil can leave stains under that armpit. If there is a stain, wash it as soon as possible. You can easily do it with available ingredients at home, like baking soda or vinegar.
Conclusion
Here we are at the end of the article. I hope my comparison of Schmidt’s and Native deodorant will help clear any confusion you have about these two products.
As you can see, natural deodorants are far superior in performance and health safety to antiperspirants. If your confusion still persists, you can try both of these deodorants and see what works best for you.