Sump pumps are an essential part of any home’s plumbing and drainage system. Installed in the lowest part of your basement, the sump pump collects water from the foundation drains and pumps it out of your home to prevent flooding.
Two of the most popular and reliable sump pump brands on the market are Myers and Zoeller. But which one is better for your home?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Myers and Zoeller sump pumps side-by-side, looking at key factors like performance, durability, warranty, customer reviews and more.
We’ll provide an unbiased assessment of the pros and cons of each brand to help you determine which is the best sump pump for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Pump Features | Myers | Zoeller |
| Pump Types | Pedestal and submersible | Pedestal and submersible |
| Materials | Thermoplastic and cast iron | Cast iron and stainless steel |
| Horsepower Range | 1/3 HP to 1-1/2 HP | 1/3 HP to 1 HP |
| Max Flow Rate | Up to 84 GPM | Up to 100 GPM |
| Warranty | 2 years | 5 years |
| Price Range | $120 – $500 | $180 – $1500+ |
| Reliability | 5-10 years | 10+ years |
| Customer Ratings | 75% 4 stars+ | 80% 4 stars+ |
| Pros | Affordable, quiet, easy to service | Powerful, durable, reliable |
| Cons | Shorter warranty, lower max flow | Expensive, heavy, costly repairs |
Key Differences Between Myers And Zoeller Sump Pumps
Myers and Zoeller are two of the most reputable and highest-rated sump pump brands. Both companies offer a range of pedestal and submersible pumps to handle drainage needs for homes of any size. Let’s look at how they stack up across some of the most important performance metrics.
- Pump Types
Myers – Offers both pedestal and submersible pumps.
Their pedestal pumps include the WP, Rustbuster, and VRS series.
Submersible models include the AH, WPX, and PHCC series.
Zoeller – Also provides both pedestal and submersible pumps.
Their M53, M63, and Aquanot series are pedestal pumps. Submersible models include the M98, Aquanot Plus, and Aquanot II series.
Verdict – Both brands offer the full gamut of pump configurations to suit any basement or application.
- Materials
Myers – Predominantly uses thermoplastic and cast iron parts across their pump lines. Their top-of-the-line models feature stainless steel shafts and hardware.
Zoeller – Relies on cast iron housing and parts for most models, with stainless steel used in their higher-end pump lines.
Verdict – Zoeller tends to use more metal components while Myers utilizes a mix of metals and thermoplastics. For durability, cast iron and stainless steel are preferable.
- Horsepower
Myers – Myers pumps range from 1/3 HP up to 1-1/2 HP motors. Their most powerful models can pump up to 84 gallons per minute.
Zoeller – Zoeller offers models between 1/3 HP to 1 HP. Their largest pumps have capacities of up to 100 GPM.
Verdict – Zoeller wins when it comes to maximum horsepower and flow rates. Their larger pumps move more water than comparably sized Myers models.
- Warranty
Myers – Most Myers sump pumps come with a 2-year manufacturer’s warranty. Some specialty models offer 3-year warranties.
Zoeller – Backed by a standard 5-year manufacturer’s warranty. Extended warranties up to 10 years are available for some models for an added cost.
Verdict – Zoeller provides an industry-leading warranty of 5 years compared to just 2 years for most Myers pumps.
- Price
Myers – Entry-level models start around $120. Their heavy-duty 1/2 HP to 1-1/2 HP pumps range from $200-$500.
Zoeller – Pricing ranges from $180 for basic models up to $1500 or more for commercial-grade stainless steel pumps.
Verdict – Zoeller commands a pricing premium, especially for their top-tier pumps. Myers offers more budget-friendly options.
- Reliability
Myers – Known for reliable pumps that can last 5-10 years with proper maintenance.
Thermoplastic parts hold up well against corrosion. Easy to service pumps due to widely available parts.
Zoeller – Very durable pumps capable of lasting 10+ years.
All metal construction and epoxy coatings prevent rust. Commercial-grade models handle constant use.
More expensive repairs since parts are proprietary.
Verdict – Both Myers and Zoeller make incredibly reliable pumps built to last. Zoeller may have a slight edge but their repairs tend to cost more when parts need replacement.
- Customer Reviews
Myers – 75% 4 stars or higher on Home Depot based on 500+ reviews. Praised for affordability, ease of installation, and quiet operation. Some complaints of premature failures.
Zoeller – 80% 4 stars or higher with 700+ Home Depot reviews. Lauded for outstanding durability and corrosion resistance. Drawbacks are high cost and heavy weight.
Verdict – Users report great experiences with both pump brands. Zoeller earns higher marks for longevity while Myers wins on price and usability.
Key Pros and Cons of Myers And Zoeller Sump Pumps
Based on their specifications, performance metrics, and customer feedback, here are the main advantages and disadvantages of Myers and Zoeller sump pumps:
Myers Pros
- Lower upfront cost
- Broad selection of pump types and sizes
- Thermoplastic parts resist corrosion
- Easy to install and service yourself
- Quiet operation
- Reliable performance for 5-10 years
Myers Cons
- Shorter 2-year warranty
- Not as powerful maximum flows as Zoeller
- Durability not on par with commercial-grade models
Zoeller Pros
- Commercial-grade durability and longevity
- Highest head pressures and flow rates
- Cast iron and metal construction
- 5-year standard warranty
- Clog-resistant design
Zoeller Cons
- Very expensive, especially for higher-end models
- Repairs cost more due to proprietary parts
- Heavy to install and service
- Overkill for some residential applications
To summarize, Myers is the more affordable DIY-friendly option while Zoeller offers maximum durability and power for a premium cost.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
For heavy duty applications, Zoeller is widely considered the leader in reliability and performance. Their commercial-grade models handle the most demanding drainage needs. However, they are overpriced for typical home use.
F.E. Myers is owned by Pentair and makes a range of residential and commercial water pumps, including sewage, effluent, and grinder pumps. Their sump pumps are assembled in the USA.
With proper maintenance like annual cleaning, a Myers sump pump will typically last 5-10 years. Heavy use or corrosive environments may reduce lifespan. Higher-end thermoplastic and stainless steel Myers models can last 10-15 years.
Zoeller is widely considered the leader in sump pump manufacturing. They offer better warranties and proven longevity of 10+ years even in harsh conditions. Wayne does make quality pumps at a more affordable price point for lighter residential use. Ultimately Zoeller is the winner if budget allows.
Conclusion
When choosing between Myers vs. Zoeller sump pumps, there are valid reasons to pick either brand. Zoeller is unmatched in terms of durability and performance but comes at a steep price. Myers provides reliable pumping at an affordable cost for most homes.
The right choice comes down to your specific needs. For frequent pumping demands or troublesome drainage, spring for a Zoeller. If you just need occasional light use in a typical basement, save money with a Myers model.
Properly maintained, either pump can provide years of flood protection. Evaluate your own basement’s requirements and choose the sump pump brand that best aligns with your budget and needs.