Molly’s Suds Vs. Charlie’s Soap: A Comprehensive Comparison

Selecting a suitable laundry detergent can be quite a task, given the multitude of options available. Today, let’s make your job easier by comparing two reputable brands – Molly’s Suds and Charlie’s Soap.

To ensure this article is a valuable resource, we’ve dissected each brand, examining the pros and cons, while focusing on aspects such as ingredients, cleaning power, environmental impact, and cost-effectiveness.

Let’s dive in!

A Brief Comparison Table

AspectsMolly’s SudsCharlie’s Soap
Key IngredientsSodium Carbonate (Washing Soda)Blend of Biodegradable Surfactants and Washing Soda
Cleaning PowerExcellentExceptional
Environmental ImpactUses Sustainable Packaging, Cruelty-freeBiodegradable, Septic-safe, Cruelty-free
Skin SensitivitySuitable for Sensitive SkinMay be Strong for Sensitive Skin
HE CompatibilityYesYes

Molly’s Suds: Pros and Cons

Molly’s Suds is a brand that positions itself as natural, safe, and eco-friendly.

  • The Pros
Molly's Suds

Molly’s Suds is lauded for its safe and natural ingredients.

It was born out of the need for a detergent free of harmful chemicals, and it prides itself on its simple, safe, and effective formula.

Its primary ingredient is sodium carbonate, also known as washing soda, a naturally occurring, pH neutral compound known for its exceptional cleaning power.

Another plus point is the brand’s commitment to sustainability. Molly’s Suds makes use of minimalistic packaging, using recycled materials and avoiding plastics when possible.

Their products are also cruelty-free, giving you peace of mind that no animals were harmed in the making.

Also Read: Problems With Whirlpool Hybrid Dryer.
  • The Cons

The cost-effectiveness of Molly’s Suds could be better. Due to the high-quality natural ingredients used, this detergent tends to be pricier compared to other brands.

Although Molly’s Suds is unscented, which is a pro for people with sensitive skin or allergies, some users might miss the fresh, clean scent typically associated with laundry.

Charlie’s Soap: Pros and Cons

Charlie’s Soap is another brand known for its gentle yet powerful cleaning abilities.

The Pros

Charlie's Soap

Charlie’s Soap is recognized for its exceptional cleaning power.

It’s great at removing tough stains and odors, providing a thorough clean with just a small amount of detergent.

It’s also very cost-effective.

One pack can last for a substantial amount of washes, making it a budget-friendly choice.

Like Molly’s Suds, Charlie’s Soap is also an eco-conscious brand. The products are biodegradable, septic-safe, and cruelty-free.

  • The Cons

The key issue with Charlie’s Soap is that some users find it too strong for delicate fabrics or sensitive skin, despite being hypoallergenic and non-toxic.

Like Molly’s Suds, Charlie’s Soap is also unscented, which could be a negative for those who prefer a fragrance post-wash.

Key Differences Between Molly’s Suds and Charlie’s Soap

Although Molly’s Suds and Charlie’s Soap share a common vision of providing eco-friendly, safe laundry options, they have distinct differences that make each brand unique. Here’s a closer look at those key differences:

  • Ingredient Profile

While both brands promote the use of safe, non-toxic ingredients, the actual ingredients used in their formulations differ. Molly’s Suds primarily uses sodium carbonate (washing soda), while Charlie’s Soap includes a blend of biodegradable surfactants and natural washing soda.

Molly’s Suds’ simpler ingredient profile may appeal to those who prefer minimalism in their cleaning products. However, Charlie’s Soap’s unique blend has won over many customers due to its superior cleaning capabilities.

  • Cleaning Power

When it comes to cleaning power, while both brands perform well, Charlie’s Soap is often praised for its ability to tackle tough stains and odors. The potent blend of biodegradable surfactants in Charlie’s Soap ensures a deep clean without the use of any harsh chemicals.

Molly’s Suds, on the other hand, relies on the natural cleaning power of washing soda, which also does an excellent job. However, some users feel that for particularly stubborn stains, Charlie’s Soap might have the edge.

  • Cost-effectiveness

While both detergents may seem pricier than regular supermarket brands, they are concentrated formulas, which means you use less per load.

That being said, Charlie’s Soap is generally considered to be more cost-effective than Molly’s Suds. This could be a significant deciding factor for households on a budget or those who do a high volume of laundry.

  • Environmental Impact

Both brands are committed to sustainability, but their approaches differ. Molly’s Suds places significant emphasis on its use of natural ingredients and sustainable packaging. On the other hand, Charlie’s Soap focuses on the biodegradability of its detergent and its septic-safe qualities.

This means if packaging sustainability is crucial to you, Molly’s Suds might appeal more. But, if your focus is more on the product’s impact post-use (like its effect on your septic system), Charlie’s Soap could be the better choice.

Remember, both brands have a commitment to being cruelty-free, so you can’t go wrong with either if animal welfare is a top concern for you.

While both Molly’s Suds and Charlie’s Soap have their pros and cons, their unique differences make them stand out in their ways. These differences can help you make an informed decision based on your individual preferences and values.

Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to what you prioritize most in a laundry detergent.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What laundry soap has the strongest scent?

Neither Molly’s Suds nor Charlie’s Soap has a strong scent as they are both unscented, focusing more on natural, hypoallergenic ingredients. If you prefer a scented laundry soap, consider looking at other brands or use a natural fabric softener or dryer sheets for fragrance.

Is Charlie’s Soap all natural?

Charlie’s Soap prides itself on its minimalistic, eco-friendly ingredients. While not 100% natural (as it does include some synthetic ingredients), it’s free from dyes, phosphates, ultraviolet brighteners, and perfumes.

What is the best HE laundry detergent to use?

Both Molly’s Suds and Charlie’s Soap are compatible with high-efficiency (HE) machines. They rinse clean, leaving no residue, which is essential for maintaining the performance and longevity of your HE washer.

What is the pH of Charlie’s Soap?

Charlie’s Soap has a neutral pH around 7. This makes it safe for most fabric types and ensures that it won’t cause irritation or allergies in most individuals.


In the end, whether you choose Molly’s Suds or Charlie’s Soap largely depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you prioritize natural ingredients and sustainability, Molly’s Suds might be the better option for you.

However, if you’re looking for something that provides a deep clean and is more cost-effective, Charlie’s Soap could be the way to go.

Whatever you choose, rest assured that both brands offer quality products that are not only effective but also conscious of their environmental impact.

Happy laundering!

Clyde Mitchell

I run a hardware store nearby Court Anaheim, CA. Over the last 7 years, I have been blogging about home improvement and yes, I own From me and this website, you can expect some useful tips on great ideas for a modern bathroom.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts