If you’re in the market for a new toilet, you’ve probably come across Kohler’s two most popular toilet families – the Wellworth and Cimarron. Both offer great value and reliable flushing performance, but which one is right for your bathroom?
In this detailed guide, we’ll compare the key features, pros and cons, and real-world performance of Kohler Wellworth and Cimarron toilets. You’ll learn how they differ in design, flushing power, water efficiency, ease of installation, pricing, and more.
By the end, you’ll know exactly which Kohler toilet suits your needs and budget. Let’s dive in!
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Kohler Wellworth | Kohler Cimarron |
| Bowl Types | Round-front, elongated | Round-front, elongated, comfort height |
| Flush Technology | Class 3 | Class 5 |
| Flushing Power | 1000 MaP score | 1000 MaP score |
| Water Usage | 1.28 gpf | 1.28 gpf |
| Toilet Height | Standard 12″ | Standard 12″, comfort height 16.5″ |
| Design Aesthetic | Basic, straightforward | Sleek, contemporary, elegant |
| Price Range | $$ | $$$ |
| Warranty | 1 year limited | 1 year limited |
Overview of Kohler Wellworth Toilets
Kohler’s Wellworth toilet line is their most affordable range.
It’s designed to provide reliable flushing performance and water savings at a budget-friendly price point.
Wellworth toilets come in both round-front and elongated bowl options to suit different bathroom layouts.
The round-front bowls offer a compact footprint, while the elongated bowls provide more comfortable seating.
For flushing, Wellworth toilets use Kohler’s Class 3 flush technology. This provides significant water savings compared to outdated 3.5 gallon models, while still delivering solid bowl-clearing performance.
Key features of Kohler Wellworth toilets include:
- Bowl shape: Round-front or elongated
- Flush technology: Class 3 flushing (1.28 gpf)
- Flush performance: 1000 gram MaP score
- Water consumption: 1.28 gallons per flush (gpf)
- Toilet height: Standard 12″ bowl height
- Price range: $$
The Wellworth is an excellent choice if you want a water-efficient Kohler toilet on a budget. The flushing performance is decent, the design is straightforward, and the pricing is quite affordable.
Overview of Kohler Cimarron Toilets
The Cimarron is Kohler’s mid-range toilet family. It offers slightly more stylish design and improved flushing power over the Wellworth, while maintaining water efficiency.
Cimarron toilets are available in round-front, elongated, and comfort height options. This extensive selection allows you to tailor the toilet to your bathroom’s dimensions and meet ADA height requirements if needed.
For flushing, Cimarron uses Kohler’s Class Five technology. This provides robust siphon flushing action that can handle more waste in one flush while still using minimal water.
Here are the key features of the Cimarron toilet line:
- Bowl shape: Round-front, elongated, and comfort height
- Flush technology: Class Five flushing (1.28 gpf)
- Flush performance: 1000 gram MaP score
- Water consumption: 1.28 gallons per flush
- Toilet height: Standard 12″ or comfort height 16.5″
- Price range: $$$
With its elegant styling and excellent flush, the Cimarron hits the sweet spot between value and performance in Kohler’s toilet lineup.
It’s a great choice if you want impressive flushing power without the premium price tag.
Detailed Comparison of Wellworth And Cimarron Toilets
Now that you have an overview of both toilet families, let’s compare them across some key categories to see how they differ.
- Aesthetic Design
Wellworth: The Wellworth has a basic, no-frills look. The tank is simple and straightforward, often with very few design elements. The styling aims for function over form.
Cimarron: Cimarron toilets feature subtle curves and detailing on the tank, giving them a more refined, contemporary style. The two-tone tank adds visual appeal.overall, the Cimarron has a more stylish, elegant look.
Verdict: Cimarron wins for design aesthetics.
- Flushing Performance
Wellworth: Uses Kohler’s Class 3 flushing system with a flush valve size of 2 1/8″.
Provides decent 1000 gram MaP flush performance rating.
Cimarron: Utilizes Kohler’s Class Five flushing technology with 2 1/4″ flush valve.
Also, achieves 1000 gram MaP score, but the larger valve and siphon-jet action create a stronger overall flush.
Verdict: The Cimarron toilet has the edge in terms of flush power and waste removal.
- Bowl Shape Options
Wellworth: Available in round-front or elongated bowl options.
Cimarron: Offered in round-front, elongated, and comfort height models. This provides more flexibility to match your bathroom layout.
Verdict: Cimarron wins for wider selection of bowl shapes and toilet heights.
- Water Efficiency
Wellworth: 1.28 gpf across all models. Meets EPA WaterSense criteria.
Cimarron: Also has 1.28 gpf water usage. Identical water savings to Wellworth.
Verdict: It’s a tie! Both toilet lines achieve excellent water efficiency.
- Noise Level
Wellworth: Standard flushing noise, no significant complaints.
Cimarron: Slightly louder flush compared to some other models, according to a few user reviews. Not a major issue.
Verdict: Wellworth may have a slight edge in terms of operating quietly. But most users don’t find noise to be a problem with either toilet.
- Ease of Installation
Wellworth: Simple, two-piece design installs without difficulty. Standard 12″ rough-in.
Cimarron: Two-piece design also easy to install. Comfort height models require 12″ rough-in while standard height uses 10″ rough-in.
Verdict: Both toilets install without hassle. Cimarron comfort height requires slightly different rough-in, but not a major issue.
- Price
Wellworth: $$ MSRP ranges from $150 – $300. Often sold around $120 – $200.
Cimarron: $$$ MSRP $350 – $700. Normally sold for $250 – $500.
Verdict: Wellworth is the clear price leader. You’ll spend noticeably more for a Cimarron model.
- Warranty
Wellworth: Covered by Kohler’s one-year limited warranty.
Cimarron: Also comes with Kohler’s one-year limited warranty.
Verdict: Same coverage either way.
Based on these key comparisons, the Cimarron toilet comes out ahead in terms of design, flush performance, and bowl shape options. But you’ll pay a higher price for those benefits compared to the budget-friendly Wellworth.
Both toilets offer reliable flushing and water savings, so the Wellworth is still a solid choice if you want to save money. Let’s take a quick look at real-world feedback from users of both models.
Wellworth and Cimarron Toilet Reviews: Key Feedback
Here are some of the most common praises and complaints about these Kohler toilets from homeowners:
Wellworth Pros:
- Good value for the price
- Straightforward installation
- Low maintenance requirements
- Provides solid flush for the money
Wellworth Cons:
- Plain, basic looking design
- Occasional clogging reported
- Some comments on improvable flush power
Cimarron Pros:
- Sleek, elegant styling
- Powerful siphon jet flush
- Comfort height models available
- Quality construction and materials
Cimarron Cons:
- Higher price tag
- Possible condensation on tank
- Toilet seat may need upgrading
Overall, most users are happy with both toilet models in terms of performance, ease of installation, and water savings. The Cimarron gets higher marks for design and flush power, while the Wellworth wins on affordability.
FAQ About Kohler Wellworth and Cimarron Toilets
Kohler’s top-selling toilet line is the Cimarron, which offers excellent performance, stylish design, and a range of bowl shapes at mid-range price points. It hits the sweet spot for most homeowners in terms of value, efficiency, and reliability.
Of Kohler’s two-piece toilets, the Santa Rosa model has the strongest rated flush at 800 grams MaP score. But several models match the Cimarron’s 1000 gram MaP rating, including the Highline, Tresham, and Wellworth. For maximum flush power, Kohler also offers pressure-assist toilets like the Highline and Cimarron that use compressed air to boost siphoning.
Yes, Kohler Cimarron toilets utilize Kohler’s Class Five flushing technology. The Class Five system provides a robust siphon jet flush through an extra-large 2 1/4″ flush valve and siphon jet hole. This creates a strong, high-efficiency flush powered by gravity and water flow rather than pressure.
Kohler, American Standard, and TOTO are among the top toilet brands based on flush performance, product quality, innovations, and customer satisfaction. Kohler offers a wide range of toilets from budget to luxury with the latest water-saving technologies. But any major brand toilet from Kohler, American Standard, or TOTO offers excellent performance if matched to your bathroom’s needs and installed properly.
The Bottom Line
When comparing the Kohler Wellworth and Cimarron toilets, the Cimarron comes out ahead in terms of design, flush power, bowl shape options, and overall performance. But you’ll pay a noticeable price premium for those benefits compared to the affordable Wellworth toilet.
Both models offer reliable flushing, low-maintenance, and 1.28 gpf water efficiency. The Wellworth is an excellent choice if you want a basic two-piece toilet that gets the job done for less.
But if your budget allows, the Cimarron is a great mid-range option that looks fabulous and provides robust flushing in a range of configurations.
By understanding the key differences in design, features, performance, and cost, you can decide whether the Wellworth or Cimarron better matches your needs. Both are quality toilets from Kohler that will serve your bathroom needs for years to come.
