Geo F. Trumper Vs. Taylor of Old Bond Street: Differences And Features

Are you looking to get the best shaving experience at home?

Then, it would help if you tried using a traditional shaving cream over canned foams and gels. They provide you with excellent cushioning and lubrication that you can’t expect from a canned one.

A classic battle of two shaving creams that you come across is Geo F. Trumper vs. Taylor of Old bond street.

Which one to pick and which one provides what? That’s what I will be discussing here today. So, if you are looking for quality shaving cream, this is where you should be.

Let’s get going.

A Quick Comparison Table

FactorsGeo F. TrumperTaylor of Old bond street
Fragrance profileCoconut oil, Citrus with a bit of cypressGeranium, rosemary, lavender, amber, with fern, sandalwood, and orange blossom
Weight7 ounces8.82ounces
LatherLight and fluffyVery Silky
ScentDecentStrong scent
Skin typeAll types of skinBest for sensitive skin

In-Depth Differences Between Geo F. Trumper And Taylor Of Old Bond Street

  • Lather Quality
Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream
Click On Image To View On Amazon

First off, the leather quality is the essential part of any traditional shaving cream you get to see out there.

The tricky part is choosing between these choices regarding the lather quality.

Both shaving creams are good with their lather production.

Usually, with Geo F. Trumper, you won’t have to use a lot of shaving cream to get a fluffy lather.

Instead, you end up with a pretty slick lather that makes your shaving experience much easier than you would expect.

On the other hand, you get a pretty decent lather with Taylor of Old Bond Street. However, if I had to compare the two, I would say Geo F. Trumper provides you with a much slicker lather in comparison.

Also, you will need to use a bit more cream with the Taylor compared to the Trumper.

So, overall, in terms of lather production and quality, I would go with Trumpers. But that’s just by a slight margin. 

  • Scent profiles

Coming to the scent profiles, the results are pretty similar. They both have a good scent, but it mostly comes down to your preferences of yourself. The flavor you like or the intensity you want dictates this whole decision.

For example, with Trumper, you will get a coconut flavor scent. So, you can pretty much assume how it will smell, and you already know whether you like the smell or not because it will smell like coconut for the most part.

But, it also has a little bit of a synthetic fragrance to it.

Taylor smells pretty good with the Sandalwood flavor. Many people tend to like the smell because of the taste itself. As for the intensity, the scent is quite good with a balance.

It’s not too strong, and it is too faint. So, if you like balance in the aroma, this is a good pick.

While it’s a very personal decision, I still think Taylor is slightly ahead in the game regarding scent profiles. So, if scent matters to you, try getting Taylor first, and then you can check out Trumper, too, if you don’t mind spending a bit of money.

  • Weight
Geo F. Trumper Shaving Cream
Click On Image To View On Amazon

Now, here is something that gives you a view of the clear difference between shaving creams.

So even though the difference is shallow on margin, there is still a difference to check.

Geo F. Trumper comes with packaging that weighs around 7 ounces.

But with Taylor, you get a packaging weight of 8.82 ounces or almost 9 ounces. So, there is a clear difference between the weight of the two options.

The real question is, how does it matter? Well, it matters because a heavier weight means more content. This means that when you choose Taylor, you will end up with a bit more cream that ensures better longevity.

However, the difference isn’t too much, so you can’t expect a considerable improvement in longevity compared to Trumpers. 

So, I wouldn’t recommend choosing a soap based on this factor because it doesn’t define anything in its truest sense.

  • Pricing and value
Geo F Trumper Rose Shaving Cream

Another factor that puts out a clear difference is the pricing. Trumpers are much more expensive than Taylor of Old Bond Street.

So, there is always that question: Is Trumpers worth the higher price?

That comes down to the value you get from the shaving cream.

In general, a Trumper soap will last the same as Taylor because Trumper doesn’t require too much soap to get a slick lather whenever you are using the soap.

At the same time, Taylor has a bit more shaving cream in the packaging, which equals the amount you can use with the shaving cream.

Considering all that, Taylor feels like a value-for-money choice. Unless the lather quality means too much to you, Taylor feels like a better pick.

Frequently Asked Question (FAQ)

There are some common questions that you will come across regarding shaving cream choices. Let’s get through them quickly.

Which is the best shaving cream in the world?

Well, it’s hard to choose a shaving cream that is the best in the world. Still, Geo F. Trumper is an excellent choice for lather quality.

How good is Taylor of Old Bond Street?

Taylor of Old Bond Street is a pretty good shaving cream you can find out there. It has a good lather, provides a great scent profile, has reasonable pricing, and comes with a good quantity for better longevity. Overall, it’s a pretty good option, especially for people with sensitive skin.

What kind of shaving cream do you use with a brush?

You will need to use soft and fluffy shaving cream when you plan to use it with a brush. Something that you can use directly with the brush.

How do you use old-fashioned shaving cream?

All you have to do is apply the shaving cream to your brush or hands. Then, use the cream on your face. Keep rubbing the cream on your face until you get the proper lather thickness. Start shaving.


To sum up, choosing one option from Geo F. Trumper vs. Taylor of Old Bond Street comes down to the scent preference for the most part because all the other factors don’t have too much difference in them.

Going with those factors can be a bit difficult to make a decision. So, the easiest way to decide between the two options is to try them both out and see which one fits your requirements more.

Clyde Mitchell

I run a hardware store nearby Court Anaheim, CA. Over the last 7 years, I have been blogging about home improvement and yes, I own ReliefInBath.comFrom me and this website, you can expect some useful tips on great ideas for a modern bathroom.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts