In the hustle and bustle of our everyday lives, one thing we often overlook is the quality of our toilet paper. Today, let’s turn that spotlight on two of the market’s leading brands, Who Gives A Crap and Charmin, and figure out which one of them is worth your money.
We’ll be comparing them based on various parameters, including quality, sustainability, cost, and more.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | Who Gives A Crap | Charmin |
| Material | Recycled/Bamboo | Virgin Pulp |
| Sustainability | High (Eco-friendly materials and packaging) | Low (Non-recycled materials and plastic packaging) |
| Charitable Efforts | 50% profits donated | No similar program |
| Texture | Comfortable but less soft | Soft and plush |
| Price | Higher (but has a subscription discount) | Lower |
| Special Features | Hypoallergenic, free from inks, dyes, and scents | Hypoallergenic, scented options available |
Pros and Cons of Who Gives A Crap
Let’s start with the environmentally conscious, Who Gives A Crap.
- Pros
The first pro for Who Gives A Crap is its environmental sustainability.
It’s made from 100% recycled materials or bamboo, which reduces deforestation and water waste.
Plus, they are packed in paper, not plastic, which is another tick for sustainability.
The company also prides itself on its charitable efforts.
A substantial 50% of their profits are donated to help build toilets for those in need worldwide.
- Cons
The price can be a sticking point for many. Who Gives A Crap can be slightly more expensive than regular toilet paper brands, although their subscription service does provide a discount.
Texture is another area where it doesn’t quite measure up to its competitors. It’s not as soft as some of the other options on the market, which may be a concern for some consumers.
Pros and Cons of Charmin
Moving onto Charmin, a familiar and well-loved brand in many households.
- Pros
Charmin is renowned for its superior softness and strength. It’s plush, absorbent, and less likely to tear during use.
Another pro is the affordability. Charmin offers high quality at a pocket-friendly price. It’s also widely available in most grocery and retail stores.
- Cons
Charmin, unfortunately, does not have the same eco-friendly profile as Who Gives A Crap. It’s not made from recycled materials, and its plastic packaging is not environmentally friendly.
Also, their high absorbency might lead to plumbing issues over time, as Charmin doesn’t dissolve as quickly as other brands.
Key Differences Between Who Gives A Crap and Charmin
Understanding the key differences between Who Gives A Crap and Charmin is crucial to make an informed decision. Let’s break down these differences across multiple aspects:
- Material
Who Gives A Crap uses 100% recycled materials or bamboo in its toilet paper.
This choice of materials has a lower environmental impact, reducing deforestation and saving water compared to traditional methods.
On the other hand, Charmin uses virgin pulp in its toilet paper, which is renowned for delivering plushness and softness but doesn’t score as high on the environmental front.
- Sustainability
Who Gives A Crap shines in this area.
Not only are their products made from recycled materials or bamboo, but they’re also packaged in paper, not plastic.
This results in less waste and a lower carbon footprint.
Charmin, while providing comfortable and high-quality toilet paper, falls behind in terms of sustainability.
Their products are not made from recycled materials, and they use plastic in their packaging.
- Charitable Efforts
Who Gives A Crap stands out for its commitment to social responsibility.
The company donates 50% of its profits to build toilets for those in need around the world.
Charmin, though a well-loved brand, does not have an equivalent charitable program tied to its sales.
- Texture
Charmin is celebrated for its softness and strength. It’s plush and absorbent, providing a luxurious feel.
Who Gives A Crap, while not as soft as Charmin, is still comfortable. It might not provide the plush feel of Charmin, but many consumers find it perfectly satisfactory.
- Price
Charmin offers high quality at a pocket-friendly price. It is a more affordable option compared to Who Gives A Crap.
Who Gives A Crap, being an environmentally and socially conscious brand, has a slightly higher price tag. However, many consumers find the extra cost justified given its eco-friendly and philanthropic approach.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
In terms of quality, it might not be the softest on the market, but it certainly holds its own. Where it shines is in its commitment to environmental sustainability and charitable contributions. If these factors are important to you, it might well be worth the extra money.
Plumbers usually recommend toilet paper that is biodegradable and breaks down quickly. While both Charmin and Who Gives A Crap are safe for most septic systems, Who Gives A Crap may dissolve faster due to its recycled materials.
The healthiest toilet paper would be hypoallergenic and free from inks, dyes, and scents. In this regard, Who Gives A Crap has an edge as all their toilet paper meets these criteria.
Yes, the bamboo version of Who Gives A Crap toilet paper is made in China. This is because China is the primary source of bamboo globally and has the necessary facilities to process bamboo into toilet paper.
Wrapping Up
In conclusion, the choice between Who Gives A Crap and Charmin depends largely on your priorities. If you value comfort and cost-effectiveness, Charmin may be the way to go.
But if sustainability and social impact hold more weight, then Who Gives A Crap would be your best bet. Choose what works best for you, and make your bathroom experience an enjoyable one!