Remi Vs. Cheeky Night Guard: In-depth Difference

I tackled both Remi and Cheeky night guards when grinding wrecked my sleep and left my jaw throbbing every morning. 

You deal with the same—needing a guard that fits well, lasts, and doesn’t add stress. 

This comparison breaks down everything: fit process, comfort, durability, service, price, real experiences, long-term value, and which one actually stops the pain. 

From my trials and months of alternating use, one shines for reliability while the other falters on consistency. 

You get the full picture here—pros, cons, table, my story, and deep analysis—so you can decide what protects your teeth best without regrets or wasted money.

My Hands-On Journey Testing Remi and Cheeky Side by Side

Grinding had turned my nights into a silent war. I’d wake up at 3 a.m. with a locked jaw, pounding headache, and the unmistakable taste of defeat. My dentist warned about enamel wear, possible cracks, and TMJ issues if I didn’t act. 

So I started researching mail-order custom guards—cheaper than $500+ dentist ones, no appointments, just impressions at home. Remi caught my eye first with its low price and “dentist-quality” claims. 

I ordered the kit for $149 (top and bottom). Box arrived in 5 days: putty packets, plastic trays, mixing sticks, prepaid envelope. Instructions were basic but clear enough. I warmed the putty in my hands, kneaded it, pressed into the trays, and bit down for the full 3 minutes. 

The putty set fast—maybe too fast in my warm room—and I worried the impression wasn’t perfect. Sealed it up and mailed it back the next morning.

Waiting period was torture—two full weeks with no updates. Finally an email: guards shipped. They arrived in plain packaging. 

First night: top guard seated okay, bottom felt loose on the left molars and pressed painfully on my gums when I clenched. I tried sleeping with them—drooled like crazy, woke up with a sore tongue from the bulk. 

Boiled them per instructions to soften and remold; helped a tiny bit, but the material didn’t hold the new shape well. By week three the edges were already wearing thin and I could see bite marks disappearing into the plastic. 

Cracks appeared by month two. Subscription auto-charged $49 for the next set without warning—I hadn’t even decided if I liked the first pair. Canceled via email—took four attempts and a credit-card dispute. 

Support responses took 3–7 days, remake request denied because “impressions looked acceptable.” I ended up with guards that made grinding worse some nights because the poor fit encouraged more clenching to “stabilize” them.

Then I ordered Cheeky. Kit arrived faster with excellent video tutorials—step-by-step on mixing putty, tray placement, bite timing. 

Impressions came out cleaner. Guards shipped in 10 days. First night: snug, almost invisible feel. 

The soft inner liner cushioned every tooth contact point—no pressure points, no gag reflex. Slept through the night for the first time in months. 

Three months later: barely any visible wear despite heavy clenching. Mornings were calm—no headache, no jaw lock. 

Optional subscription was clear and easy to pause. Asked support one question via chat—answered in under 10 minutes. 

No hidden fees, no pressure. Partner noticed I was less irritable during the day.

Alternated them for two more months to compare fairly. Remi nights: restless, shifting, irritated gums, chemical aftertaste. 

Cheeky nights: peaceful, secure, no soreness. Cleaned both daily—Remi warped slightly from one too-hot water rinse; Cheeky bounced back. Jaw pain dropped 70–80% with Cheeky; Remi hovered at 30% improvement at best. 

Cost over six months: Remi ended up more expensive after remakes, replacements, and dispute time. Cheeky higher upfront but zero extra charges or stress. 

Buddy tried both—same conclusion: Cheeky felt “premium and trustworthy,” Remi “cheap and risky.” Analytically, Cheeky wins on consistency, material quality, service trust, and actual symptom relief. 

Remi gambled on fit luck; Cheeky engineered reliability. If I could go back, I’d start with Cheeky—saved me months of pain and frustration.

Key Features of Remi Night Guard

Remi positions itself as the budget-friendly mail-order custom guard. You order the kit ($149 for top and bottom), receive putty and trays, make impressions at home, mail them back, and wait 2–4 weeks for thermoplastic guards. 

Material is BPA-free, dual-layer: hard outer shell for protection, softer inner for comfort. Thickness options include thin (for light grinding), standard, and thick (for severe cases). Boil-and-bite allows minor adjustments after arrival. 

Subscription plan auto-ships replacements every 6 months for $49. Kit includes prepaid envelope, basic instructions, and a case. Guards aim for breathability with perforations to reduce drool and improve airflow. 

No dentist visit needed—big selling point for people who hate appointments or live far from clinics.

On paper the features look solid: affordable entry into custom territory, flexibility in thickness, and subscription convenience for ongoing protection. Boil adjustment sounds user-friendly. BPA-free material checks safety boxes. Prepaid shipping removes hassle.

But real-world delivery often falls apart. Impressions are sensitive—warm hands, room temperature, bite force all affect accuracy. 

Many users (including me) end up with uneven molds leading to loose spots or high-pressure points that actually worsen grinding by encouraging compensatory clenching. 

Material feels stiff compared to premium options; soft layer doesn’t cushion as well as claimed. 

Boil-and-bite helps some, but the plastic loses shape retention over time—users report guards becoming floppy after a few adjustments. Subscription sounds smart until auto-renew hits without clear reminders; cancellation requires multiple emails and often credit-card intervention. 

Breathability perforations are small—drooling still happens for mouth breathers. Chemical/plastic taste is common in the first week or two. Kit instructions are short and lack troubleshooting for common errors (e.g., bubbles in putty, shallow bite). 

Support is email/chat only, with average 3–7 day response times. Analytically, Remi targets cost-conscious beginners who want to avoid dentist prices, but skimps on quality control and post-purchase support. 

For mild grinders who get lucky with fit, it can work as a starter. For moderate to severe bruxism, the risk of poor fit, fast wear, and service frustration outweighs the savings. You end up paying in pain, time, and additional purchases anyway.

Key Features of Cheeky Night Guard

Cheeky delivers a premium-feeling mail-order custom guard experience. You order the kit ($149 for one arch, $218 for both), receive high-quality putty, trays, mixing tools, and detailed video tutorials. 

Impressions are easier thanks to step-by-step guidance on bite depth, tray placement, and common mistakes. 

Guards are fabricated from durable acrylic-based material with a soft inner liner for cushioning. 

Thickness options: standard 2mm (most users) or extra durable 3mm (heavy grinders). Low-profile design minimizes bulk and awareness during sleep. 

Optional subscription ($229 annual or quarterly) is completely transparent—no auto-renew surprises, easy to pause or cancel online. 

Guards are HSA/FSA eligible. Remake policy is straightforward—if fit is off, send photos and they remake at no extra charge. Support is chat-based and typically responds in minutes to hours.

Features focus on user experience from start to finish. Video guides reduce impression errors dramatically. Material combination (hard outer for protection, soft liner for comfort) balances strength and cushioning. 

Low-profile construction means less gag reflex and drooling than bulkier guards. Durability is a standout—many users report 6–12 months of heavy use with minimal wear. 

Subscription is optional and clearly communicated—no hidden charges. HSA/FSA eligibility adds practical value. 

Service is responsive and solution-oriented—users feel heard. Analytically, Cheeky prioritizes quality control, comfort engineering, and trust-building post-purchase support. 

The material holds shape longer and distributes clenching force more evenly, reducing jaw fatigue. Breathability is good—perforations and low profile help airflow. No chemical taste reported by most users. 

Process is faster (10–14 days typical). You get a guard that feels custom-made because it usually is—impressions are more forgiving and fabrication more precise. 

For moderate to heavy grinders, the extra upfront cost is offset by fewer replacements, less pain, and no service battles. 

Cheeky suits people who want reliability without dentist prices or endless frustration.

How Remi and Cheeky Compare on Fit and Comfort

Both use mail-in impressions for custom fabrication. Remi outcomes vary dramatically—temperature, bite force, and putty mixing affect accuracy. 

Many users (including me) end up with loose spots that shift during sleep or high-pressure points that cause gum irritation and new soreness. 

Material is stiffer, bulkier—leads to drooling, gag reflex, and tongue bite. Boil-and-bite adjustment helps some, but shape retention is poor—guards lose molded form over time. 

Cheeky fits snugger from the first night—low-profile design sits naturally against teeth. Soft inner liner distributes clenching force evenly, eliminating pressure points. 

Stays secure without shifting. Drooling minimal, gag reflex rare. No adjustment needed for most—impressions more forgiving thanks to video guides. 

You feel Remi as an intruder; Cheeky becomes invisible. Analytically, Cheeky superior in fit consistency and thoughtful engineering. 

Remi risks irritation and non-compliance; Cheeky encourages nightly use. Comfort directly impacts effectiveness—Cheeky wins for real-world relief.

Durability Battle Between Remi and Cheeky

Remi material thins and cracks quickly—moderate to heavy grinders see visible wear in 3–6 months. 

Edges fray, bite marks disappear into plastic, structural integrity fails. Cheeky resists abrasion far better—6–12 months with minimal thinning even under strong clenching. 

Material holds shape longer, less deformation from heat or saliva. You replace Remi more often—cost and hassle add up. 

Cheeky requires fewer replacements, saving money long-term. Remi softens over time; Cheeky maintains firmness. 

Analytically, Cheeky material formulation stronger—better engineering for bruxism forces. 

Remi fails severe cases; Cheeky handles intensity. Durability determines real protection—Cheeky wins hands-down.

Customer Service Showdown

Remi support relies on email and chat—average 3–7 day response times. Remake requests frequently denied even with clear photos of poor fit. 

Cancellation of subscription requires multiple emails, often fails—users resort to credit-card disputes. 

Cheeky uses live chat—responses in minutes to hours. Remakes are straightforward: send photos, they remake at no extra charge. Subscription optional and easy to pause/cancel online. 

You feel heard with Cheeky; ignored with Remi. Analytically, service quality shapes overall trust—Cheeky builds loyalty; Remi loses customers fast.

Price and Value Analysis

Remi starts at $149 for both arches—lower entry. Cheeky $149 for one, $218 for both—higher upfront. 

Remi subscription $49 every 6 months; Cheeky optional $229 annual. 

Remi appears cheaper initially, but frequent remakes, replacements, and service fights add cost. 

Cheeky higher start but lasts longer—fewer purchases needed. You calculate Remi total cost higher over 12 months. 

Analytically, Cheeky better long-term value—quality reduces hidden expenses.

Remi Night Guard Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Budget price for custom kit.
• Home convenience no appointments.
• Thickness varieties.
• Subscription replacements.
• BPA-free safe.
• Adjustment boil.
• Top/bottom choices.
• Free ship.

Cons:

• Fit inconsistencies.
• Fast wear.
• Slow support.
• Charge surprises.
• Remake denials.
• Taste chemical.
• Bulk discomfort.
• Cancel hard.

Pros attract with low entry barrier. Budget price appeals to people avoiding $400+ dentist guards. 

Home kit skips scheduling and travel. Thickness options theoretically match grinding severity. 

Subscription promises ongoing protection. BPA-free material checks safety box. Boil adjustment gives DIY control. Top/bottom flexibility suits needs. Free shipping kit removes barrier.

Cons dominate real experiences. Fit varies wildly—impressions sensitive to temperature, bite force, mixing errors. 

Many end up loose or tight, causing new pain. Material wears fast—heavy grinders see cracks in weeks. Support slow—3–7 day replies, remake requests often denied despite evidence. 

Subscription auto-charges surprise users; cancellation requires persistence. Initial chemical/plastic taste lingers for some. Bulkier design causes drooling, gag, or tongue irritation. 

Analytically, Remi sacrifices quality control and post-purchase support to hit low price. 

Pros strong on paper; cons in practice turn savings into stress. You end up paying in pain, time, and extra purchases. 

Remi suits very light grinders who get lucky with fit; most users regret it.

Also Read: My Experience With Dentek Night Guard

Cheeky Night Guard Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Comfort profile low.
• Durable material.
• Remakes easy.
• Support responsive.
• Subscription optional.
• HSA eligible.
• Guides video.
• TMJ effective.

Cons:

• Price higher.
• Impression tricky.
• Thickness limited.
• Delays shipping.
• No boil tweak.
• Manage subscription.
• Online mostly.
• Soft too.

Pros center on reliability and user experience. Low-profile comfort is standout—nights pass unnoticed. Durable material lasts longer than most mail-order guards. Remakes are straightforward—no fights or denials. 

Support is fast and helpful—chat responses in minutes. Subscription optional and transparent—no sneaky charges. 

HSA/FSA eligibility adds real-world value. Video guides reduce molding errors significantly. Effective for TMJ and grinding relief—users report less morning pain.

Cons are minor and manageable. Higher upfront price reflects quality. Impression still requires care (though easier than Remi). Thickness options fewer than some competitors. Occasional shipping delays. 

No boil-and-bite adjustment (not needed for most). Subscription requires manual management. Online-only purchase. Some find soft liner too yielding for extreme grinding. 

Analytically, pros far outweigh cons—quality justifies cost. You get consistent relief, fewer replacements, and trust. Cheeky delivers on promise where Remi often fails.

Also Read: My Thoughts On Remi Mouth Guard 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Final Thoughts

Both aim to stop grinding damage, Cheeky outperforms in fit, durability, comfort, and service.

You should choose Cheeky for reliable, hassle-free protection. It transformed my sleep; it can do the same for you.