Are you looking for a new boiler for your home and can’t decide between a New Yorker and a Burnham?
Fret no more, we’ve got your back!
In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll break down everything you need to know about these two top-tier boiler manufacturers.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | New Yorker Boilers | Burnham Boilers |
| Energy Efficiency | Generally Higher | Varies by Model |
| Maintenance Costs | Typically Lower | Can be Higher |
| Longevity | 15-30 years with maintenance | 15-25 years with maintenance |
| Initial Cost | Can be Higher | Varies by Model |
| Availability | Primarily in the U.S. | More Globally Available |
New Yorker Boilers: Pros and Cons
New Yorker boilers are renowned for their durability and efficiency. This American-based company takes pride in delivering dependable heating solutions for homes across the country. Let’s delve into the specifics.
Pros of New Yorker Boilers
- Longevity
One of the key strengths of New Yorker boilers is their longevity.
With a lifespan of 15 to 20 years on average, these boilers can even last up to 30 years with regular maintenance.
- Wide Range of Models
Whether you need a gas, oil, or steam boiler, New Yorker has got you covered. They offer a comprehensive selection of models, making it easy for homeowners to find a boiler that suits their specific needs.
- Efficient Operation
New Yorker boilers boast high energy efficiency ratings, which can lead to significant savings on your energy bills over time.
Cons of New Yorker Boilers
- Limited Availability Outside the U.S.
Although New Yorker is a widely recognized brand in the U.S., their boilers can be harder to find in other parts of the world.
- Higher Initial Costs
Compared to some competitors, New Yorker boilers can be a bit pricier upfront. However, this cost is often offset by the boiler’s efficiency and longevity.
Burnham Boilers: Pros and Cons
Burnham boilers, another trusted name in the industry, offer homeowners reliable, high-performance heating solutions. Here’s a closer look at what they bring to the table.
Pros of Burnham Boilers
- Superior Performance
Burnham boilers are celebrated for their robust performance, with models offering both high efficiency and superb heating capabilities.
- Wide Selection
Like New Yorker, Burnham also offers a wide range of models, including gas, oil, and steam boilers, making it easier for you to find a product that fits your specific requirements.
- Durability
Burnham boilers are designed to last, with an average lifespan of around 15 to 25 years.
Cons of Burnham Boilers
- Higher Maintenance Costs
While Burnham boilers are generally durable, they can be more costly to maintain than some competitors due to their complex designs.
- Less Energy Efficient
While Burnham boilers offer solid performance, some models may not be as energy efficient as those offered by other brands like New Yorker.
Key Differences Between New Yorker and Burnham Boilers
Understanding the key differences between New Yorker and Burnham boilers can help you make a more informed decision. Although they both offer quality heating solutions, their products have certain distinguishing characteristics.
- Boiler Types
Both New Yorker and Burnham offer a range of boiler types fueled by either natural gas, heating oil, or electricity.
New Yorker
- Energy Star certified gas boilers with AFUE up to 95%
- Oil-fired cast iron boilers and indirect water heaters
- Electric boilers up to 99% efficient
Burnham
- High-efficiency gas boilers with AFUE up to 97.3%
- Oil-fired water and steam boilers
- Electric boilers with stainless steel construction
No matter which fuel type you need, both brands provide efficient boiler solutions for hydronic heating systems.
- Energy Efficiency
While both brands offer high-efficiency models, New Yorker boilers generally edge out Burnham in terms of energy efficiency.
This means that New Yorker boilers may result in lower energy bills over time, making them a potentially more cost-effective solution in the long run.
- Maintenance Costs
When it comes to maintenance, Burnham boilers can be somewhat costlier to maintain due to their complex design. This complexity can make repairs more intricate and potentially more expensive.
On the other hand, New Yorker boilers tend to be simpler in design, often resulting in lower maintenance costs.
- Longevity
In terms of longevity, both brands offer durable and reliable boilers. However, New Yorker boilers have been reported to last longer on average.
While both can range between 15-25 years, New Yorker boilers have instances of lasting up to 30 years with regular maintenance.
- Initial Cost
Both brands vary in cost depending on the specific model and its features. However, New Yorker boilers can be a bit pricier upfront.
That said, it’s important to consider the long-term costs, including energy efficiency and maintenance costs, as these can significantly affect the total cost of ownership.
- Smart Controls
Intelligent controls optimize performance and simplify operation.
New Yorker
- Optional WiFi thermostats for remote monitoring
- Simple dial thermostats on budget models
Burnham
- Advanced touchscreen Orion controllers
- Optional Enviro-Tec controls with outdoor reset and night setback
Burnham boasts some of the smartest integrated boiler controls for maximizing efficiency. New Yorker relies more on basic thermostats.
- Reputation
Both companies have been manufacturing boilers for decades and enjoy good reputations.
New Yorker
- Over 30 years in business
- Positive customer reviews
- Good value for price point
Burnham
- Over 140 years in business
- Very loyal customer following
- Known for high quality and reliability
As one of the oldest boiler brands, Burnham has earned an excellent reputation after a century of service. New Yorker also satisfies many homeowners at its lower price point.
- Warranties
A good boiler warranty provides peace of mind against early part failures.
New Yorker
- 10 year limited warranty on heat exchanger
- 1 year on parts
Burnham
- 10-12 year limited warranty on heat exchanger
- 1-5 years on parts
The warranties are evenly matched with 10+ years of coverage on the vital heat exchanger components. Burnham extends parts coverage longer in some models.
- Availability
New Yorker boilers are primarily available in the United States, which might limit their accessibility for customers outside the country. Burnham boilers, on the other hand, have a wider global availability.
These differences underscore the importance of assessing your specific needs and priorities when choosing between a New Yorker and Burnham boiler.
Whether it’s energy efficiency, maintenance costs, longevity, initial cost, or availability, understanding these key differentiators will help guide you to the heating solution that best suits your home.
Which Is the Better Buy?
For those seeking a compact workhorse boiler at a crowd-pleasing price, New Yorker is hard to beat. Burnham certainly carries elite status but comes at luxury cost.
Weigh your budget, efficiency goals, and sizing needs to decide which brand offers the optimal package.
And no matter which you choose, work with a professional for proper installation and maintenance. Both New Yorker and Burnham make quality boilers with the potential for years of efficient heating.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Absolutely! Burnham boilers are known for their excellent performance and durability, making them a reliable choice for home heating systems.
New Yorker boilers have a strong reputation for durability, typically lasting anywhere from 15 to 20 years, and can even extend up to 30 years with regular maintenance.
On average, a Burnham boiler should last between 15 and 25 years with appropriate care and maintenance.
New Yorker boilers are proudly manufactured in the United States. They are a staple American brand, trusted by homeowners across the country for their heating needs.
Top boiler brands known for reliability include Burnham, Weil-McLain, Navien, Lochinvar and Triangle Tube. Look for established companies using high grade materials like stainless steel and cast iron in heat exchanger construction.
Leading boiler companies include Burnham, Weil-McLain, Lochinvar, Navien and Buderus. All offer high efficiency gas and oil boilers built to last using robust materials and proven technology.
Final Thoughts
By considering these factors, you can make an informed decision about whether a New Yorker or Burnham boiler is the right choice for your home.
Remember, it’s not just about the initial purchase price but also factors such as energy efficiency, maintenance costs, and lifespan. Choose wisely, and enjoy the warmth!