Member’s Mark Toilet Paper Review: Is It Worth It?

When it comes to something as essential as toilet paper, we all want quality without breaking the bank.

I’ve been through my fair share of brands, some better than others, and when I came across Member’s Mark Ultra Premium Bathroom Tissue, I wasn’t sure what to expect. Could a store brand from Sam’s Club really stack up to the big names like Charmin or Kirkland? Spoiler: it did.

Let me share my honest experience with this toilet paper, from its quality to cost-effectiveness, and why I’ve become a dedicated fan.

My Experience With Member’s Mark Toilet Paper

When I first opened the package, the first thing I noticed was how soft it felt.

I’m someone who appreciates a good balance between strength and softness, and Member’s Mark Ultra Premium Bathroom Tissue didn’t disappoint.

It’s not overly plush like some high-end brands, but it’s not rough either.

If you’ve ever used cheaper toilet paper that feels like sandpaper, you know how important this balance is.

Another feature that stood out is the strength of the paper. The rolls are thick and absorbent, and I’ve found that you really do use fewer sheets per session, which adds to the overall value.

Unlike some brands where you need to bunch up a large amount to avoid any unfortunate accidents, Member’s Mark provides enough strength to ensure that doesn’t happen. There’s no tearing or shredding, and thankfully, it’s septic-safe as well.

What I Love About Member’s Mark Toilet Paper?

After using Member’s Mark for a while, there are several things that I absolutely love about it, and these are the reasons I’ll continue to repurchase.

• Value for Money

To me, toilet paper is one of those things where you want quality but don’t necessarily want to overspend.

Member’s Mark hits that sweet spot perfectly.

For the price you pay, you get a large number of rolls (usually around 45 rolls per pack).

I’ve found that it lasts longer than many other brands, and because you need fewer sheets to get the job done, it stretches your dollar even further.

Compared to Charmin or even Kirkland, Member’s Mark holds its own while costing significantly less.

• Soft and Gentle on Skin

Some toilet papers can be rough and leave you feeling uncomfortable, but not this one. Member’s Mark Ultra Premium is soft and gentle on the skin, which is a major plus for me. I’ve had no irritation, and it doesn’t leave behind any residue or particles, which I’ve noticed with other brands. It’s like a perfect middle ground between luxury and practicality.

• Absorbency and Thickness

Another big pro is the thickness and absorbency. A little goes a long way, and that means you don’t need to tear off massive amounts just to feel clean. The paper itself is durable, and I haven’t noticed any issues with it falling apart during use.

Plus, it’s great at absorbing moisture quickly, which is important for maintaining hygiene.

• Septic-Safe

If you’re like me and live in a home with a septic system, you know how important it is to use a toilet paper that won’t cause any plumbing issues.

Member’s Mark is septic-safe, meaning it breaks down easily without clogging pipes or septic tanks. I haven’t had any issues with it in the months that I’ve been using it, which gives me peace of mind.

Cons: Where It Could Improve?

While I’m definitely a fan of Member’s Mark toilet paper, there are a couple of minor cons that are worth mentioning.

• Roll Size: One thing I did notice is that the rolls are slightly smaller compared to some other brands. While the quality is definitely better than many competitors, you do get a slightly shorter roll, which might be a downside if you’re someone who doesn’t want to change the roll often. That being said, I still found the product lasted me longer than expected because of the fewer sheets needed per use.
• Delivery Issues: If you’re ordering online, there can be occasional issues with shipping and delivery. Personally, my order took a bit longer to arrive than expected, and I’ve read reviews from others who’ve had similar experiences. The product itself is worth the wait, but if you’re in a hurry, this might be a downside.

Comparison With Other Brands

When it comes to toilet paper, we all have our favorites, but how does Member’s Mark toilet paper hold up when compared to other brands like POM Toilet Paper, Who Gives A Crap, and Fiora Toilet Paper?

Let’s break it down:

• POM Toilet Paper

POM is often seen in bulk in places like big-box stores and warehouses, and while it’s known for its affordable pricing, it doesn’t quite match the quality of Member’s Mark.

POM toilet paper is thinner and less plush, which means you might need to use more sheets to achieve the same level of cleanliness and comfort.

POM is sturdy but lacks the softness and absorbency that Member’s Mark delivers.

If you’re after sheer value and are less concerned about texture, POM can be a solid choice, but for a more luxurious feel, Member’s Mark is the better option.

• Who Gives A Crap Toilet Paper

Who Gives A Crap stands out because it’s made from recycled materials and has a strong eco-friendly message.

If environmental sustainability is your top priority, this brand is a great pick.

However, it tends to be a bit rougher in texture compared to Member’s Mark, which focuses more on softness and strength.

While I appreciate the environmental angle of Who Gives A Crap, it doesn’t offer the same level of comfort and durability in each sheet.

On the flip side, Member’s Mark strikes a balance between being absorbent, soft, and strong, while still being reasonably eco-friendly (with its septic-safe label), making it a good middle ground for those who want comfort without compromising too much on sustainability.

• Fiora Toilet Paper

Fiora Toilet Paper is another brand positioned as a budget-friendly option, but it falls short in both strength and softness compared to Member’s Mark. Fiora is thinner and not as plush, meaning you’ll end up using more per use, which diminishes its overall value.

While Fiora is cheaper, Member’s Mark delivers a more premium experience at a price point that still beats many high-end brands.

Fiora might be good in a pinch, but if you’re looking for toilet paper that combines thickness and absorbency without the risk of tearing or leaving behind particles, Member’s Mark is the clear winner here.

Tips: Making The Most Of Your Toilet Paper

Believe it or not, there are some simple ways you can make your toilet paper last longer and improve your overall experience:

• Proper Storage: Make sure to store your toilet paper in a dry, cool place. Excess moisture can cause the rolls to deteriorate, especially if you live in a humid environment. I’ve found that keeping the rolls in a dedicated bathroom cabinet helps maintain their quality.
• Avoid Overuse: Because Member’s Mark toilet paper is thick and absorbent, you really don’t need to use a lot. Try to get into the habit of using fewer sheets; you’ll be surprised at how well it works. This is especially important for households with kids who might overdo it!
• Septic System Maintenance: If you have a septic system, make sure to perform regular maintenance to keep everything running smoothly. Even though Member’s Mark is septic-safe, it’s always a good idea to have your system checked periodically to avoid any clogs or issues.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: Why Member’s Mark is My Go-To Choice?

In conclusion, Member’s Mark Ultra Premium Bathroom Tissue has completely changed the way I view store-brand toilet paper. It offers a fantastic combination of softness, strength, and value that surpasses many of its competitors.

From its absorbency to the fact that it’s septic-safe, this is a product that I’ll continue to repurchase. Whether you’re looking for something that’s budget-friendly or just want to upgrade your toilet paper game, Member’s Mark delivers on all fronts.

I highly recommend buying this product either from Sam’s Club directly or through Amazon if you don’t have a membership. You won’t be disappointed with the quality, and your wallet will thank you, too!