Kitsch Vs. Earthling Co Shampoo Bar: In-depth Differences

Choosing the right shampoo bar can be a game-changer for your hair care routine, especially if you’re looking to make a sustainable switch.

Today, I’m here to share my experience with two popular shampoo bars: Kitsch and Earthling Co. If you’re trying to decide which one is right for you, this article will provide all the details you need.

We’ll compare their pros and cons, and I’ll share my personal take on each.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Kitsch Shampoo Bar	Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar
Ingredients	Natural, Vegan, Sulfate-Free	Natural, Vegan, Sulfate-Free
Hair Types	All Hair Types	All Hair Types
Scents	Variety of Scents	Variety of Scents
Price	Mid-Range	Mid-Range
Eco-Friendliness	Zero Waste, Compostable Packaging	Zero Waste, Compostable Packaging
Longevity	Lasts up to 100 washes	Lasts up to 50-75 washes
Manufactured In	China	USA
Ideal for Oily Hair	Yes	Yes

Kitsch Shampoo Bar

Pros

1. Eco-Friendly Packaging: One of the first things that caught my eye about Kitsch shampoo bars is their commitment to eco-friendly packaging. The bars come in compostable packaging, making them a great choice for reducing plastic waste.
2. Vegan and Cruelty-Free: If you’re concerned about animal welfare, you’ll be pleased to know that Kitsch products are vegan and cruelty-free. They don’t contain any animal-derived ingredients, and no animals are harmed in the production process.
3. Variety of Scents: Kitsch offers a variety of scents to choose from. Whether you prefer something floral, fruity, or earthy, there’s likely a scent that will appeal to you.
4. Suitable for All Hair Types: These bars are designed to work well with all hair types, from straight to curly and everything in between. They also help to maintain the natural balance of your scalp.
5. Lasts Up to 100 Washes: One bar can last up to 100 washes, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.

Cons

1. Availability: Depending on where you live, Kitsch products might not be readily available in local stores. This means you might have to order online, which can sometimes result in shipping delays.
2. Manufactured in China: For some, the fact that Kitsch products are manufactured in China might be a downside due to concerns about manufacturing practices or wanting to support more local businesses.
3. Scent Strength: Some users have reported that the scents are quite strong, which might not be ideal if you prefer more subtle fragrances.

Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar

Pros

1. Manufactured in the USA: Earthling Co. shampoo bars are made in the USA, which can be a significant plus if you prefer supporting American-made products.
2. Zero Waste: Just like Kitsch, Earthling Co. is dedicated to reducing plastic waste. Their packaging is fully compostable, aligning with a zero-waste lifestyle.
3. Gentle Formula: The formula is gentle and designed to work well with all hair types, including color-treated hair. It doesn’t contain sulfates, which can be harsh and strip your hair of natural oils.
4. Great for Oily Hair: If you have oily hair, you’ll find that Earthling Co. shampoo bars help to control excess oil without leaving your hair feeling greasy.
5. Natural Ingredients: These bars are packed with natural ingredients, which are gentle on your hair and scalp.

Cons

1. Price: While both brands are mid-range, some might find Earthling Co. to be slightly pricier than Kitsch, especially considering the number of washes each bar provides.
2. Longevity: Earthling Co. shampoo bars tend to last between 50 to 75 washes, which is less compared to Kitsch. This might mean you’ll need to repurchase more frequently.
3. Limited Availability in Stores: Similar to Kitsch, you might have to order Earthling Co. shampoo bars online, as they aren’t always available in local stores.

Key Differences Between Kitsch And Earthling Co. Shampoo Bars

When it comes to choosing between Kitsch and Earthling Co. shampoo bars, understanding their key differences can help you make a more informed decision. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what sets these two brands apart.

• Ingredients and Formulation

Kitsch shampoo bars are formulated with a variety of natural, vegan ingredients designed to cleanse and nourish your hair.

They are free from sulfates, parabens, and synthetic fragrances, which makes them suitable for all hair types, including sensitive scalps. Kitsch emphasizes using gentle, plant-based ingredients that maintain the natural balance of your scalp.

Earthling Co. also prioritizes natural and vegan ingredients, ensuring their products are free from sulfates, silicones, and parabens.

What sets Earthling Co. apart is their focus on using ingredients that specifically benefit oily hair, such as kaolin clay and tea tree oil. These ingredients help to absorb excess oil and keep your scalp feeling fresh longer.

• Scents and Fragrance

Kitsch offers a wide range of scents, from floral to fruity, catering to different preferences.

The scents are relatively strong and linger in your hair, providing a lasting fragrance.

This can be a plus if you enjoy noticeable scents, but might be overwhelming if you prefer subtler fragrances.

Earthling Co. shampoo bars have more subtle scents compared to Kitsch.

They use essential oils and natural fragrances that provide a pleasant, but not overpowering, scent.

This is ideal for those who are sensitive to strong fragrances or prefer a more subdued aroma in their hair care products.

• Longevity and Usage

One of the standout features of Kitsch shampoo bars is their longevity. A single bar can last up to 100 washes, making it a cost-effective option. The bars produce a rich lather, which helps in evenly distributing the product through your hair, ensuring thorough cleansing with each use.

Earthling Co. shampoo bars typically last between 50 to 75 washes. While they might not last as long as Kitsch bars, they still offer good value for their price.

The bars produce a decent lather, though it might not be as rich as Kitsch, but still effective in cleansing your hair.

• Manufacturing Location

Kitsch products are manufactured in China. While this allows for cost-effective production, some consumers might have concerns regarding manufacturing practices or a preference for supporting more local businesses.

Earthling Co. shampoo bars are made in the USA. This can be a significant factor for those who prefer to buy American-made products, supporting local businesses and ensuring adherence to strict manufacturing standards.

• Price Point

Kitsch shampoo bars are priced in the mid-range category. Given their long-lasting nature (up to 100 washes), they offer good value for money. However, the initial cost might be slightly higher compared to other brands.

Earthling Co. shampoo bars are also mid-range in price. Although they might be slightly pricier per bar compared to Kitsch, especially considering their shorter lifespan (50 to 75 washes), the quality of ingredients and the brand’s ethical manufacturing practices can justify the cost for many consumers.

• Effectiveness for Oily Hair

Kitsch shampoo bars are suitable for all hair types, including oily hair. However, they don’t specifically target oily hair concerns. They help maintain the natural balance of your scalp but might not be as effective in controlling excess oil compared to Earthling Co.

Earthling Co. shampoo bars are particularly good for oily hair. Ingredients like kaolin clay and tea tree oil help absorb excess oil and keep your scalp feeling fresh for longer periods. This makes them an excellent choice if you struggle with oily hair and need a product that specifically addresses this issue.

My Personal Take

• Using Kitsch Shampoo Bar

When I first tried the Kitsch shampoo bar, I was immediately impressed by the lather it produced. It felt luxurious and rich, much like traditional liquid shampoos. The scent was quite strong, which I personally enjoyed, but I can see how it might be overpowering for some.

Using it over several weeks, I noticed my hair felt clean and well-moisturized. The bar didn’t dry out my scalp, which is something I’ve struggled with using other shampoo bars.

However, I did find that it took a bit longer to rinse out compared to liquid shampoos.

• Using Earthling Co. Shampoo Bar

Switching to the Earthling Co. shampoo bar, I found the experience to be equally pleasant but in different ways. The scent was more subtle, which was a nice change. The bar produced a good amount of lather, though not as much as Kitsch.

What stood out to me was how my hair felt after using it. It felt incredibly soft and manageable. Even though my hair tends to get oily quickly, the Earthling Co. bar helped keep the oiliness at bay longer than my usual shampoo.

Which One Is Better?

Deciding between Kitsch and Earthling Co. really comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a stronger scent and a longer-lasting bar, Kitsch might be the better choice.

However, if you prioritize supporting American-made products and need something specifically good for oily hair, Earthling Co. could be the way to go.

Both brands offer fantastic eco-friendly options, so no matter which one you choose, you’ll be making a positive impact on the environment.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Wrapping Up

Choosing between Kitsch and Earthling Co. shampoo bars can be a bit of a challenge, but it’s a good problem to have. Both brands are committed to providing eco-friendly, vegan, and cruelty-free products that are kind to your hair and the planet.

From my personal experience, you really can’t go wrong with either. It ultimately comes down to your specific needs and preferences. Whether you choose Kitsch for its strong scents and longer-lasting bars, or Earthling Co. for its gentle formula and effectiveness on oily hair, you’ll be taking a step towards a more sustainable lifestyle.

Now it’s up to you to decide which one suits you best!